Will the SEC Approve Bitcoin ETFs in 2023 or 2024?

The crypto market is abuzz with anticipation of Bitcoin ETFs (Exchange Traded Funds) and a fair share of skepticism.

The United States Securities and Exchange Commission’s (SEC) hesitant stance on crypto assets, contrasted against a growing demand for Bitcoin ETFs, has sparked a vigorous debate amongst investors and financial institutions alike.

Interest Grows for a Spot Bitcoin ETF

Bitcoin’s price trajectory tells a tale of heightened optimism. With its value climbing to $30,716.24, it marked a 2.7% hike at the week’s outset. This uptick is spurred by a hopeful sentiment surrounding Bitcoin ETFs. It also comes amidst heightened trading activity and a regulatory maelstrom that has historically shadowed the crypto’s liquidity.

Investors are eyeing the end of 2023 through the first half of 2024 as the potential window for a Bitcoin ETF approval. This expectation is fueled further by several firms amending their SEC filings recently to address earlier concerns, a move perceived as a positive engagement between the SEC and these firms.

Read more: How To Trade Bitcoin Futures and Options Like a Pro

SEC Commissioner Hester Peirce’s remarks shed light on the internal dynamics of the regulatory body. While expressing her long-standing support for a Bitcoin ETF, Peirce candidly shared her mystification over the SEC’s reluctance.

She hinted at the Grayscale ETF case’s crucial role in this scenario. Yet, her inability to gauge her colleagues’ approach underscores this topic’s inherent uncertainty.

“I really can’t speak to what we’re going to do on the Bitcoin exchange-traded products. I can say that generally, the agency has not been very good when it comes to anything related to Bitcoin or other crypto assets. And, look, I hope that they’ll wake up and they’ll think, you know what, we need to take a more productive approach. That hasn’t happened yet,” Peirce said.

Furthermore, Peirce acknowledged the palpable interest from firms and investors in Bitcoin ETFs. However, she cautioned against over-reading the tea leaves to predict the SEC’s next move. This could leave the market in hopeful anticipation mingled with uncertainty.

The Promises of Diversification

This narrative unfolds amidst a broader, albeit cautious, acceptance of ETFs in the financial industry. In 2016, Vanguard CEO Bill McNabb voiced concerns over the rapid proliferation of ETFs. He drew parallels with the 1980s mutual fund scenario, which did not end well.

“The industry is [introducing a new] ETF, it feels like, every 30 seconds. This is like the 1980s and mutual funds. Things did not end well for all those funds… We have to be very careful. If we go too far as an industry, people will have doubts about the original construct. And some categories are pretty esoteric,” McNabb said.

Despite these concerns, the ETF landscape witnessed explosive growth, crossing the 10,000 mark globally at the end of September.

The larger context, which weighs the allure of crypto and the promise of diversification they offer against the risks and regulatory hurdles, nestles the discourse around Bitcoin ETFs. The past performance of specialized ETFs, which according to a study, suffered a risk-adjusted loss of about 30% over their first five years, casts a long shadow of doubt over the viability and performance of a potential Bitcoin ETF.

Read more: How To Buy Bitcoin (BTC) and Everything You Need To Know

The crypto market, however, driven by the narrative of “what could be,” continues to demonstrate resilience against these concerns. A blend of high-profile endorsements, amended SEC filings, and rising Bitcoin prices have fashioned a market ripe with expectations.

“The fact that the SEC chose to ask questions is a change in behavior. Therefore, I do think hopes are rising that a – or a number of – Bitcoin ETFs will be approved,” CEO of Ark Invest Cathie Wood affirmed.

Regulatory hurdles and the need for a productive approach from the SEC pave the road to a Bitcoin ETF. Yet, the allure of a diversified investment vehicle like a Bitcoin ETF and a market thirsty for innovation keep the hope alive.

“I cannot talk about the specifics of anything but this is an example of the pent-up interest in crypto and what we hear from clients around the world about the need for crypto. I think some of this rally is way beyond the rumor,” BlackRock CEO Larry Fink said.

Only time and a more progressive regulatory outlook will tell if the SEC will approve any Bitcoin ETF.